Dear Sam L Eadie,
Since I have my roots in the south of Gotland, where Burgsvik is situated, and have researched there for many years, I would like to add just a couple of small notes to your interesting story about the research for the right background of Axel Theodor Hessel - even if I have no answer.
1. I am sure you are aware of the text about Hessel in Nyberg: Gotländska släkttavlor: page 104 about the Ockander family:
Birgitta Olivia ( Ockander ), född 13/10 1848, död. Gift i Othem 3/9 1867 med teknologen Axel Theodor Hessel, född i Söderköping 18/6 1842.
Anyway I wanted to add it here.
There, he is listed to be born in Söderköping in 1842 as you can see, and probably that information is taken from the church record of Othem.
2. I am bound to agree to your suggesting that Axel Theodor so to say had adopted the identity of a relative of his.
Strangely enough I have found that sort of enterprise for at least two emigrants already. One case concerns a girl emigrating from Västergötland. She seems to have adopted her sister's identity. Probably her sister had leased an emigration certification from the parish pastor and then regretted that. She did not want to emigrate. Her sister, on the other hand wanted, took the identity papers and went. At least that is how her descendants in Chicago and I believe.
One sister disappears from the church records without any notes, the other one stays there. The remaining sister's identity lives on in Chicago, too. Probably the missing sister! Why this happened nobody can understand. Lack of time to get new identity paper? Running away from something?
Another case, more difficult to solve: About a man emigrating from Värmland first to Norway, and after a couple of years on to the USA. His identity fits with a man in Värmland, but that one remained there and married. The other man married in Norway and then went quickly away to America. Who he was, I am now, probably in vain, trying to find out. He might perhaps have bought the other man's identity papers in Norway, since the supposed owner of the papers really was in Norway at the actual time.
Your case seems more strange. According to your story he appears to have adopted his new identity already in Sweden. You have checked all birth records of Söderköping I guess for all the years between say 1837 and 1845? All the surrounding parishes?
In the US census people obviously could give up the year and place of birth as they liked. So it seems, since I have found that many of the Swedish emigrants made themselves at least two years younger there than they were, and the name of the birth parishes could be whatever. At sea was a note for man, whose background I have researched, born far from the coast in the Swedish inland, for instance.
The emigrants could not imagine how difficult those false notes were to be for their descendants! One woman from Västergötland, as an example, had made herself five years younger than she was. The American descendants had always believed her. How they, and I, searched in Sweden!
What is the name of the cousin you suspect is Axel, the emigrant? As I have written above I find it difficult to believe he could have adopted his new identity already in Sweden. If so, it is very interesting. Could he really dare to go around in this country with its very strict laws of those days, with the identity of another living man?
Kerstin Jonmyren
Ljungbyholm
E-mail: swedgenco@home.se